TripAdvisor CEO Goes On Defensive After Scathing Review
Well, that struck a chord.
A recent column in the U.K.’s Guardian newspaper poured scorn on TripAdvisor. That’s nothing new – the massive review site is a frequent target of criticism. But this time something clearly irked TripAdvisor CEO Steve Kaufer, and he responded with a 1,400 word rebuttal.
Food and travel critic Marina O’Loughlin slammed the company, taking shots at everything from its integrity to Kaufer’s eye-popping salary, estimated in 2013 at $39 million. “I don’t hate it [TripAdvisor] because it enables reviews of and tickets for cruel animal attractions, or for its climate of blackmail-enabling entitlement,” wrote O’Loughlin. “I hate it because it’s shit.” Ouch.
In particular, she disparages TripAdvisor’s listings of top restaurants or hotels, claiming some are “utterly fictitious,” and how awards are handed out to hotels that are no longer in business, such as the property in Tunisia at the centre of a terrorist attack in the summer of 2015.
After outlining various episodes involving TripAdvisor, she concludes: “Please don’t mistake this for the frustrated bleatings of a dead tree media fossil threatened by the mighty onslaught of citizen journalism. For one thing, I am writing this from the perspective of a punter, not a pundit. For another, while I welcome many voices, this internet clamour isn’t turning us into a democratic utopia, but rather something that resembles the film Idiocracy, in which a man wakes up after 500 years in a world of, well, idiots. I’m not against the idea of a source of unbiased, fact-checked, crowd-sourced wisdom. But TripAdvisor ain’t that.”
In his rebuttal, Kaufer says he disagrees with “almost all” of O’Loughlin’s points.
“What is interesting is that the criticisms I hear often come from 2 opposite ends of the debate. On the one hand, there are those who say we should engage in greater levels of censorship to counter fraudulent reviews. On the other hand, we are critiqued that our guideline process is too stringent. Both viewpoints are flawed in their own unique ways.
“By giving customers a voice we have helped millions of travellers take better trips. Professional critics are free to disagree, but I am going to stand by the hundreds of millions of travellers and millions of business owners who also know from their own experience that TripAdvisor is a force for good for both the traveller community and for the global travel industry.”